Demon Seed Pixel Art Process
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5edf6/5edf69ed13ef3c5f30bf6780dbb39fff2c98135f" alt="Demon Seed"
This is the cover to Demon Seed, a HOT new Castlevania 3 remix by one of my favorite musicians, Joshua Morse.
When I make art for Joshua, I'm always intimidated because my design needs to "sit on the same shelf" as his amazing music. To make it the best it can be, I take as much time as I can and put the design through its paces.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/28dbc/28dbcb57d5dcfdc272b73ee11a46dc60c66dd450" alt="Demon Seed sketch 1"
First I wanted to just start sketching to loosen up. Rather than going with whatever nonsense might be in my head, I went straight to the source and doodled a level from Castlevania 3.
This was not the direction we decided to go, but that's good information to have.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/76c78/76c78667740ddae3453014d05b22236ae468a953" alt="Demon Seed sketch 2"
For the next sketch, I wanted to keep some of the elements that I liked drawing and looking at from the first sketch. Spikes, cubes, maybe some bats -- it looks more three-dimensional and it still felt like a Castlevania level.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2926e/2926efdf33117e6e996da93f56ba4105f2a4943b" alt="Demon Seed pixel rough"
One fear of mine is that I'll forget I'm working on pixel art and try to bite off more than I can chew. High resolution pixel art is time-consuming and difficult to pull off, so I wanted to try a quick pixel rough to see where this was headed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9872e/9872e8ab45414e5d20b78393ddc42d35df554d39" alt="Demon Seed color rough"
Coloring and shading are important for a piece like this, so I continued on to ensure things weren't getting out of hand. Sure enough, as I colored I was seeing signs that the resolution was too high for me to handle with the time I had. I'd need to use a smaller canvas, which meant fewer elements and a simpler environment would be best.
Also, the words "Demon Seed" are so cool but look a little lost in this iteration. More emphasis on the title would benefit the design.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8c054/8c05483fed2271ed69d294c2b7a31ec19ff1ffe2" alt="Demon Seed sketch 3"
After having gone through some paces, I had a good idea of what I could and wanted to make. The title would have a bigger role, which takes pressure off of the environment. The blocks stayed, along with some floating spikes and a skull because, ya know, Castlevania. I blocked everything out and it felt reasonable.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ee5d2/ee5d2173f1cd34c11d8fe256ab27190971982a1c" alt="Demon Seed WIP 1"
Next I began to render the pixels. I could tell immediately that the resolution was more my speed and at this size I'd be able to make a better overall design.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/97404/97404616c02f5021d8446035907ab62e661dcdd2" alt="Demon Seed WIP 2"
Lastly I added the first pass of color. It looks anemic at this stage, but at low resolutions the detail can really shine, so I went straight into shading and polish.
You can see the final cover above, on DeviantArt, or on PixelJoint.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c6e66/c6e661b5d2bc1f80000d76ae084f06df94aa5694" alt="Demon Seed process"
Here's the entire process. The end result is not as good as VLAD II but here we are. If I could do anything differently, I would have added more detail like creatures and treasure scattered around the blocks. Make it feel mossy by covering the surfaces ...
Now that I think about it, this Demon Seed piece came before Happy Surfaces, and could have unconsciously laid the groundwork for it! More on that later.